Best Handmade Aftershaves - Buying Guide
Last Updated: 05/03/2024
Share on
Bestselling Handmade Aftershaves on Amazon
- Thor's Hammer Fire & Ice Aftershave for Men, Travel Size 1.7 oz.
- Bay Rum Aftershave, Thor's Hammer Bay Rum Limited Edition Round Bottle, 8 oz
- Thor's Hammer Original Aftershave, Viking Axe Aftershave, All Natural and Handmade, 1.7 oz
- Rustic Charm Farm Goat Milk Aftershave Lotion (Bay Rum)
- Thor's Hammer Original Aftershave, Viking Axe Aftershave, All Natural and Handmade, 5 oz
- Lime Bay Rum Aftershave Limited Edition, Thor's Hammer Bay with Lime, All Natural, 8 oz
- Buddha After Shave Moisturizer for Men
- Zero Waste Bay Rum After Shave Splash
- Bay Isles Shaving Company: All Natural Aftershave with Aloe and glycerin (After Midnight 2oz)
- Spice Aftershave, Thor's Hammer Nordic Spice, Special Gift Edition 2 oz
#1
Thor's Hammer Fire & Ice Aftershave for Men, Travel Size 1.7 oz.
Asin: B088NVVX55
Features
- All natural and handmade in Montana, USA.
- 1.7 oz glass bottle with orifice reducer, perfect for travel.
- No artificial colors, fragrances or preservatives.
- See more on Amazon...
No Artificial Colors, Fragrances Or Preservatives..
1.7 Oz Glass Bottle With Orifice Reducer, Perfect For Travel..
Brand: Freyja's Magic
See On Amazon #2
Bay Rum Aftershave, Thor's Hammer Bay Rum Limited Edition Round Bottle, 8 oz
Asin: B0C9C25BL3
Features
- All natural and handmade in Montana, USA.
- Scented with pure essential oils for aromatherapy benefits.
- 8 oz amber glass with t-top cork. To open, carefully score the sealing wax near the base and peel away.
- See more on Amazon...
8 Oz Amber Glass With T-Top Cork. To Open, Carefully Score The Sealing Wax Near The Base And Peel Away..
Scented With Pure Essential Oils For Aromatherapy Benefits..
Brand: Freyja's Magic
See On Amazon #3
Thor's Hammer Original Aftershave, Viking Axe Aftershave, All Natural and Handmade, 1.7 oz
Asin: B0BSMSWMK8
Features
- All natural and handmade in Montana, USA.
- Scented with pure essential oils for aromatherapy benefits.
- 1.7 oz glass bottle with removable orifice reducer.
- See more on Amazon...
1.7 Oz Glass Bottle With Removable Orifice Reducer..
Scented With Pure Essential Oils For Aromatherapy Benefits..
Brand: Freyja's Magic
See On Amazon #4
Rustic Charm Farm Goat Milk Aftershave Lotion (Bay Rum)
Asin: B0786S94LL
Features
- MADE FROM FRESH GOAT MILK- Goats' milk is an excellent natural source of vitamins and minerals that will give you healthy skin. Our herd of Nigerian Dwarf goats provide the milk for farm-fresh products.
- SUPPORT SMALL BUSINESS- Rustic Charm Farm is a family owned and operated farm in rural Eastern Kentucky.
- See more on Amazon...
Support Small Business- Rustic Charm Farm Is A Family Owned And Operated Farm In Rural Eastern Kentucky..
Brand: Rustic Charm Farm
See On Amazon #5
Thor's Hammer Original Aftershave, Viking Axe Aftershave, All Natural and Handmade, 5 oz
Asin: B0BSMMSYMR
Features
- All natural and handmade in Montana, USA.
- Scented with pure essential oils for aromatherapy benefits.
- 5 oz glass bottle with removable orifice reducer.
- See more on Amazon...
5 Oz Glass Bottle With Removable Orifice Reducer..
Scented With Pure Essential Oils For Aromatherapy Benefits..
Brand: Freyja's Magic
See On Amazon #6
Lime Bay Rum Aftershave Limited Edition, Thor's Hammer Bay with Lime, All Natural, 8 oz
Asin: B09J1HKTZ3
Features
- All natural and handcrafted in Montana, USA.
- Contains no added colors, natural or artificial fragrances, just pure spices and essential oils.
- 8 oz glass bottle with cork top and gift bag.
- See more on Amazon...
8 Oz Glass Bottle With Cork Top And Gift Bag..
Contains No Added Colors, Natural Or Artificial Fragrances, Just Pure Spices And Essential Oils..
Brand: Freyja's Magic
See On Amazon #7
Buddha After Shave Moisturizer for Men
Asin: B08BGZM7NY
Features
- Hazelnut: Tightens, nourishes, absorbs very quickly into the skin.
- Juniper Essential Oil: A mild astringent, this essential oil helps reduce the appearance of acne, enlarged pores, and redness.
- Handmade in small batches using natural ingredients!
- See more on Amazon...
Handmade In Small Batches Using Natural Ingredients!.
Juniper Essential Oil: A Mild Astringent, This Essential Oil Helps Reduce The Appearance Of Acne, Enlarged Pores, And Redness..
Brand: Mojo Spa
See On Amazon #8
Zero Waste Bay Rum After Shave Splash
Asin: B0B2M4Q57Z
Brand: Dancing Orchid Soapworks
See On Amazon #9
Bay Isles Shaving Company: All Natural Aftershave with Aloe and glycerin (After Midnight 2oz)
Asin: B0CYNQRZJV
Mostly Organic.
All Natural.
Brand: Generic
See On Amazon #10
Spice Aftershave, Thor's Hammer Nordic Spice, Special Gift Edition 2 oz
Asin: B08HYP7H81
Features
- All natural and handmade in Montana, USA.
- Masculine spice scent created with pure essential oils.
- 2 oz frosted glass bottle with leather cap and gift bag.
- See more on Amazon...
2 Oz Frosted Glass Bottle With Leather Cap And Gift Bag..
Masculine Spice Scent Created With Pure Essential Oils..
Brand: Freyja's Magic
See On Amazon #11
Lime Bay Rum Aftershave Balm, Thor's Hammer Classic Bay Rum with Lime, Viking Aftershave Lotion, 4 oz (Metal Bottle)
Asin: B0CXZWVBNG
Features
- All natural and handmade in Montana, USA.
- Our best selling lime bay rum balm now in a shatter-proof bottle!
- Scented with real lime, West Indies Bay oil and organic spices.
- See more on Amazon...
Scented With Real Lime, West Indies Bay Oil And Organic Spices..
Our Best Selling Lime Bay Rum Balm Now In A Shatter-Proof Bottle!.
Brand: Freyja's Magic
See On Amazon #12
Fire and Ice Aftershave, Viking Aftershave, Thor's Hammer Fire and Ice, Limited Edition 5 oz.
Asin: B083RJ32SK
Features
- All natural and handmade in Montana, USA.
- 5 oz limited edition with cork top and gift bag.
- No artificial colors, fragrances, or preservatives.
- See more on Amazon...
No Artificial Colors, Fragrances, Or Preservatives..
5 Oz Limited Edition With Cork Top And Gift Bag..
Brand: Freyja's Magic
See On Amazon #13
Bay Rum Aftershave, Thor's Hammer Bay Rum, New Glass Bottle with Orifice Reducer, 5 oz
Asin: B0CTLJG2MY
Features
- New 5 oz Limited Edition featuring a removable orifice reducer!
- All natural and handmade in Montana, USA.
- Scented with pure essential oils for aromatherapy benefits.
- Linen gift bag included.
- See more on Amazon...
Scented With Pure Essential Oils For Aromatherapy Benefits..
Linen Gift Bag Included..
All Natural And Handmade In Montana, Usa..
Brand: Freyja's Magic
See On Amazon #14
Magnanimous All-Natural After Shave Oil - The best all-natural after shave oil on the planet - Zeus approved!
Asin: B0CC9VH6RT
Features
- All-Natural and Organic Certified Ingredients
- Old School Barber Shop Scent
- Non-Greasy
- Great for Razor Burn, Razor Bumps, and Dry Skin Relief
- See more on Amazon...
Non-Greasy.
Great For Razor Burn, Razor Bumps, And Dry Skin Relief.
Old School Barber Shop Scent.
Brand: Magnanimous Beard Products
See On Amazon #15
Bay Rum Aftershave, Thor's Hammer Bay Rum, Frosted Glass Special Edition, 2 oz
Asin: B09NP7Q13G
Features
- All natural and handcrafted in Montana, USA.
- Scented with pure West Indian Bay oil.
- 2 oz frosted glass bottle with orifice reducer, leather cap and gift bag.
- See more on Amazon...
2 Oz Frosted Glass Bottle With Orifice Reducer, Leather Cap And Gift Bag..
Scented With Pure West Indian Bay Oil..
Brand: Freyja's Magic
See On Amazon #16
Men's All-Natural Fountain of Youth After Shave Balm - After Shave Balm for Men - Aftershave Balm - Razor Burn Treatment - Post Shave Balm - Post Shave Balm Men
Asin: B0C56M6KNS
Features
- Our All-Natural Fountain of Youth After Shave Balm offers a convenient, inexpensive way to keep your skin feeling fresh and looking great.
- Our After Shave Balm isn't just for your face, either - you can use it anywhere else you need extra moisture (sunburns often cause skin irritation, so having our after-shave balm on hand can help improve the appearance and feel of skin quickly after a day in the sun).
- Our After Shave Balm is packaged in a 2-ounce reusable tin. It includes a small cosmetic spatula/spoon for easy application, and to avoid contamination to the balm by using your fingers.
- To use: Immediately after shaving, rinse your face with cold water. Ensuring face is still damp, take a small dollop of balm using the included cosmetic spatula and gently massage into the freshly shaved skin.
- Ingredients: Beeswax, Jojoba Oil, Sweet Almond Oil, Mango Butter, Shea Butter, Argan Oil, Vitamin E, Spilanthes, Ginger, Gotu Kola, Calendula, White Willow Bark, Witch Hazel Leaf, and Rosemary ~ with Lavender, Cedarwood, and Tea Tree Essential Oils.
- See more on Amazon...
Our After Shave Balm Is Packaged In A 2-Ounce Reusable Tin. It Includes A Small Cosmetic Spatula/Spoon For Easy Application, And To Avoid Contamination To The Balm By Using Your Fingers..
Ingredients: Beeswax, Jojoba Oil, Sweet Almond Oil, Mango Butter, Shea Butter, Argan Oil, Vitamin E, Spilanthes, Ginger, Gotu Kola, Calendula, White Willow Bark, Witch Hazel Leaf, And Rosemary ~ With Lavender, Cedarwood, And Tea Tree Essential Oils..
To Use: Immediately After Shaving, Rinse Your Face With Cold Water. Ensuring Face Is Still Damp, Take A Small Dollop Of Balm Using The Included Cosmetic Spatula And Gently Massage Into The Freshly Shaved Skin..
Our After Shave Balm Isn't Just For Your Face, Either - You Can Use It Anywhere Else You Need Extra Moisture (Sunburns Often Cause Skin Irritation, So Having Our After-Shave Balm On Hand Can Help Improve The Appearance And Feel Of Skin Quickly After A Day In The Sun)..
Brand: High Thyme FARMacy
See On Amazon #17
Billy Goat Aftershave - 2oz
Asin: B079KMMLQS
Brand: Steele Family Farm
See On Amazon #18
USA Vegan Organic Handmade Healing Herbal Oil. Soothes and repairs dry itchy skin. Weak and damaged skin issues Aftershave Rash bug bites wounds and cuts
Asin: B0BRBRV8CW
Features
- Vegan and Organic ingredients
- FOR TOPICAL USE ONLY. DO NOT ingest
- HOW TO USE: a little goes a long way; use on clean skin; apply up to 2 times daily for best results. Patch test to ensure no reactions occur.
- Helps with acne, rashes, stretch marks, dry skin, eczema, blemishes, promoting cell repair, diaper rashes, bruises, insects bites, skin infections.
- Ingredients: Organic neem oil, jojoba oil, tea tree oil, infused organic calendula flowers, organic avocado oil, organic black seed oil, sweet almond oil, moringa oil
- See more on Amazon...
How To Use: A Little Goes A Long Way; Use On Clean Skin; Apply Up To 2 Times Daily For Best Results. Patch Test To Ensure No Reactions Occur..
Ingredients: Organic Neem Oil, Jojoba Oil, Tea Tree Oil, Infused Organic Calendula Flowers, Organic Avocado Oil, Organic Black Seed Oil, Sweet Almond Oil, Moringa Oil.
Helps With Acne, Rashes, Stretch Marks, Dry Skin, Eczema, Blemishes, Promoting Cell Repair, Diaper Rashes, Bruises, Insects Bites, Skin Infections..
For Topical Use Only. Do Not Ingest.
Brand: Generic
See On Amazon #19
Eau de Cologne 8oz. Aftershave Balm
Asin: B07L9H7FWH
Brand: Generic
See On Amazon #20
Bar Soap and Aftershave 4oz Candle | Glass Jar 4oz | Vegan Soy Wax | Handmade Small Business | Lasts 40+ Hours
Asin: B084KZQTS6
Features
- Experience the pure, clean burn of our premium-quality soy wax candles, meticulously handcrafted for an eco-friendly experience. Made from soy wax, these candles are toxin-free and produce minimal soot or smoke, ensuring a healthier environment for you and your family. Embrace a safer, greener way to illuminate your home with our high-quality soy wax candles.
- Our soy wax candles feature pure cotton wicks for a cleaner, healthier burn. Unlike traditional wicks, cotton wicks produce minimal soot and are more enviromentally friendly, ensuring a safer and more enjoyable fragrance experience. Enjoy our cotton wick candles for a purer scent and improved air quality in your home.
- Discover the luxurious aroma of our soy wax candles, each infused with premium fragrance oils for a superior scent experience. Our carefully curated selection offers a variety of unique and classic fragrances, designed to suit every mood and occasion. Elevate your senses with our exclusive range of high-quality scents, ensuring a memorable aromatic journey with every candle.
- Enjoy the charm of our handmade candles, lovingly crafted by our small, family-owned, woman-led business. Each candle receives personal attention, showcasing the dedication and passion of our team. Experience the beauty and quality that only true craftsmanship can offer with our lovingly made candles, a reflection of our family's commitment to excellence.
- Our soy wax candles are the perfect gift for any occasion. With unique scents and elegant packaging, they are ideal for birthdays, anniversaries, housewarmings, and more. Each candle offers a long-lasting burn and exquisite fragrance, adding warmth, comfort, and ambiance to any space. Give a thoughtful, luxurious gift that truly enhances any environment.
- See more on Amazon...
Discover The Luxurious Aroma Of Our Soy Wax Candles, Each Infused With Premium Fragrance Oils For A Superior Scent Experience. Our Carefully Curated Selection Offers A Variety Of Unique And Classic Fragrances, Designed To Suit Every Mood And Occasion. Elevate Your Senses With Our Exclusive Range Of High-Quality Scents, Ensuring A Memorable Aromatic Journey With Every Candle..
Our Soy Wax Candles Are The Perfect Gift For Any Occasion. With Unique Scents And Elegant Packaging, They Are Ideal For Birthdays, Anniversaries, Housewarmings, And More. Each Candle Offers A Long-Lasting Burn And Exquisite Fragrance, Adding Warmth, Comfort, And Ambiance To Any Space. Give A Thoughtful, Luxurious Gift That Truly Enhances Any Environment..
Enjoy The Charm Of Our Handmade Candles, Lovingly Crafted By Our Small, Family-Owned, Woman-Led Business. Each Candle Receives Personal Attention, Showcasing The Dedication And Passion Of Our Team. Experience The Beauty And Quality That Only True Craftsmanship Can Offer With Our Lovingly Made Candles, A Reflection Of Our Family's Commitment To Excellence..
Our Soy Wax Candles Feature Pure Cotton Wicks For A Cleaner, Healthier Burn. Unlike Traditional Wicks, Cotton Wicks Produce Minimal Soot And Are More Enviromentally Friendly, Ensuring A Safer And More Enjoyable Fragrance Experience. Enjoy Our Cotton Wick Candles For A Purer Scent And Improved Air Quality In Your Home..
Brand: Only The Best Candles
See On Amazon
Looking For Something Else?
Search